From My Notebook – Part 4

CATEGORY: Little Pieces Of Life



The Roles We Assign to Others


In every human relationship, there are expectations that are expressed and others that remain unspoken. We expect people to understand us, respond to our needs, offer us security or recognise the things we consider important. Some of these expectations develop through getting to know one another and sharing experiences. Others, however, may exist long before the relationship begins. It is as though we have already prepared a place for someone in our personal story and, when a person who moves us comes along, we invite them to occupy it. We do not necessarily ask them in words to become something different. We may expect it silently, taking for granted that they will understand what we need and how they ought to respond. In this way, the relationship begins to take shape not only through what actually happens between two people, but also through an unwritten role that each may have assigned to the other.

Let us consider a man who, from an early age, has been accustomed to taking responsibility for the people around him. He was the one who tried to maintain peace at home, who looked for solutions whenever difficulties arose and who felt a particular sense of satisfaction when he could be of help. As he grew older, he retained this aspect of his character. In his friendships, he was always available; at work, he took on more than his share of responsibilities; and in his personal relationships, he found it difficult to admit that he, too, needed care. One day, he meets a woman who is going through a difficult period in her life. She tells him about her disappointments, the relationships that have hurt her and her difficulty in trusting people. The man is moved by her story and wishes to be there for her. He listens attentively, offers his help and tries to show her that she can rely on him.

At first, their relationship develops with tenderness. He feels that his presence holds particular significance for her, and the woman finds someone who is willing to listen. Gradually, however, the man begins to imagine that his love will help her overcome all her difficulties. He believes that if he remains patient enough, offers her the security she has lacked and proves that he is different from those who have hurt her, she will be able to trust again. This thought gives him the feeling that their relationship has a special purpose. He is not simply a man who loves a woman. He is the one who will help her find herself again. Without realising it, he has begun to write a story in which his devotion will inevitably lead to her transformation.

Yet real life does not always follow the scripts we create. The woman may continue to experience difficulties, may need time or may not want the help he considers necessary. She may even have different expectations of their relationship. When he discovers that his efforts are not bringing about the change he anticipated, he begins to feel disappointed. He feels that what he offers goes unrecognised and that his love is not enough. Perhaps he becomes angry when she does not follow his advice or feels hurt when she tries to face a difficulty on her own. Gradually, his desire to help her may become connected to a deeper personal need: to feel significant through the care he offers her. If she succeeds in overcoming her difficulties, he will feel that his presence in her life has held particular value.

Here, the fantasy does not necessarily concern a mistaken image of the woman. It concerns primarily the role the man has assumed within the relationship. He has connected his sense of personal worth with his ability to help, protect and offer solutions. The possibility that she may not need his help or may not change in the way he expects can bring him face to face with an uncomfortable question: who is he within this relationship if he is not the person who saves the other? And perhaps this question is more difficult than the disappointment itself. For it invites him to recognise that his need to give may also be connected to a deeper personal desire: to feel indispensable, significant and worthy of love.

Of course, this is not the only role people may assume. Someone else may constantly seek a partner who will protect them from every difficulty. They may imagine that love means never having to feel alone, uncertain or vulnerable again. Another person may wish always to be the one who is chosen, pursued and placed at the centre of attention. And someone else may have become so accustomed to striving for acceptance that they feel more strongly attracted to people who remain emotionally distant. These roles are not necessarily conscious decisions, nor can they fully explain a person’s choices on their own. They can, however, offer a way of understanding why certain relationships feel so familiar to us, even when they cause us difficulties.

Sometimes, two people may come together precisely because their expectations appear to complement one another. One wishes to care for someone, while the other wishes to be cared for. One constantly seeks reassurance, while the other feels significant when they become the centre of attention. Such a connection is not necessarily problematic. Mutual care, support and the need for closeness are natural aspects of human relationships. The difficulty arises when these roles become so rigid that people can no longer exist outside them. When the person who cares for others is not allowed to grow tired, the person who protects is not allowed to feel afraid, and the person who needs help is not encouraged to discover their own strengths. The relationship then risks becoming confined to a story with predetermined characters, in which every change seems to threaten its balance.

Perhaps one of the most difficult moments in a human relationship comes when the other person no longer fulfils the role we have assigned to them. When the person we considered weak begins to stand on their own two feet, when the one we believed would always protect us acknowledges their own vulnerability or when the partner from whom we expected constant reassurance begins to ask for more personal space. We may then feel that something is changing within the relationship, even if that change is part of its natural development. We need to get to know the person before us once again, this time without taking for granted who they ought to be for us.

Perhaps, ultimately, a meaningful encounter with another person begins when we are able to allow them to exist beyond the story we had imagined. When we recognise that they are not obliged to fulfil all our expectations, heal our old wounds or confirm the image we have created of ourselves. They can love us without saving us, support us without making decisions for us and remain close to us without always agreeing with us. And we, for our part, can discover that our personal worth does not depend entirely on the role we have grown accustomed to assuming. Perhaps then the relationship begins to make more room for two real people, with their needs, strengths and weaknesses, rather than two characters attempting to follow a script that was written before they had even met.

The End…

PsyCatherine.com

Our Blog Timeline

Scroll to Top