CATEGORY: Little Pieces Of Life
The Person We Fell in Love With and the One We Imagined
Dora met Demosthenes one autumn afternoon at the home of mutual friends. It was not one of those encounters that seemed to promise anything significant. They sat next to each other almost by chance and talked about books, travel and a film they had recently seen. He had a calm way of conversing, never interrupted, listened attentively and, when Dora spoke about something personal, seemed genuinely interested. As she left that evening, she realised that she had spent quite some time without looking at her phone, without thinking about the following day’s responsibilities and without feeling the need to make herself interesting. She had simply enjoyed a conversation. And yet, as she made her way home, she began to think about Demosthenes in a way that went far beyond what had actually happened between them.
Over the following days, she often returned to that encounter in her mind. She remembered his facial expressions, the way he smiled and certain things he had said that had made an impression on her. His calmness led her to believe that he was an emotionally mature person. The attention with which he had listened gave her the feeling that he would be able to understand her even in her most difficult moments. His love of travel and literature made her imagine someone with whom she could share an entire world of experiences. She did not yet know how he handled disagreements, how he behaved when he was tired, what he wanted from a relationship or whether he even wished to enter into one. Nevertheless, an image had already begun to take shape within her: that of a man who embodied many of the qualities she had been searching for over the years.
When they met again, Dora did not arrive with only the memory of a pleasant afternoon. She also brought with her the image she had created in the intervening time. Demosthenes had now become, in a sense, two people: the one she had actually met and the one she had begun to know through her imagination. These two images were not necessarily contradictory. The second had grown out of the first, but it had been enriched with qualities, possibilities and expectations that had not yet been confirmed.
The Idealisation of the Loved One
At the beginning of a romantic relationship, the other person remains, to a large extent, an unexplored world. We know certain aspects of their character, some of their habits and perhaps a few significant experiences from their life. There is, however, still much that we do not know. And it is precisely within this space of the unknown that imagination often finds the freedom to wander. A quality that fascinates us may acquire greater significance than it actually possesses. A kind gesture may lead us to conclude that the other person is always patient and understanding. A profound conversation may make us believe that we have met someone with whom we will never again feel emotionally alone. A shared interest may become the starting point for an entire vision of a life together. From the few pieces of information available to us, we begin to create a complete picture, often without distinguishing which parts come from the other person and which come from ourselves.
Idealisation is a psychological process through which we attribute particularly positive qualities to another person, often placing greater emphasis on their virtues and less on their weaknesses. In romantic relationships, it may be expressed through the enthusiasm we feel for the other person, the special significance certain behaviours acquire in our eyes or the belief that we have met someone unlike anyone we have known before. We do not necessarily invent qualities that do not exist. We may simply give existing qualities a scope and significance that extend beyond what we actually know. The person who made us laugh one afternoon may become, in our minds, the one who will bring joy into our lives. The person who listened to us with genuine interest may become the one we believe will always understand us.
In psychoanalytic thought, idealisation is closely associated with romantic emotional investment. In exploring the nature of love, Sigmund Freud observed that the loved one may acquire a special place in a person’s psychological life by embodying qualities that they admire and consider valuable. From this perspective, romantic love concerns not only the other person’s actual qualities, but also the significance those qualities acquire within our inner world. Sometimes, the person we fall in love with seems to embody something we had been searching for long before we met them: a sense of security, a promise of freedom, a form of tenderness or a way of life that fascinates us. Meeting them then acquires a significance that cannot be explained solely by what is happening in the present. It is also connected to a personal history of desires, needs and expectations.
What We See and What We Wish to See
Let us return to Dora and Demosthenes. They continued to see each other and, over time, a relationship developed between them. Dora discovered that many of the qualities that had fascinated her during their first encounter were indeed aspects of his character. Demosthenes enjoyed conversation, had a sense of humour, was interested in the arts and appreciated occasional escapes from everyday life. However, she also discovered other sides of him. He needed considerable time alone, found it difficult to talk about his feelings when something was troubling him and did not always feel comfortable discussing the future of their relationship. The calmness that had so fascinated her at the beginning did not mean that he could handle every emotional difficulty with the same ease. And his ability to listen did not mean that he would always understand her needs.
At first, Dora did not attach much importance to these differences. When he avoided a conversation about the future, she believed that he needed more time. When he withdrew after a disagreement, she thought that he was trying to protect their relationship from unnecessary tension. When he did not respond to her need for more communication, she assumed that he was not yet accustomed to expressing his feelings. These interpretations might have been correct. Other explanations, however, were also possible. What is interesting is that Dora tended to choose the interpretations that preserved the image she had already created of him. Rather than asking herself what Demosthenes’ behaviour actually meant, she was more concerned with finding a way to understand it that was consistent with what she already believed about him.
This tendency is not uncommon in human relationships. Once we have formed a strong impression of someone, we often find it easier to notice the things that confirm it, while finding it more difficult to give equal attention to those that challenge it. In romantic love, where emotional investment can be particularly intense, revising our image of the other person is not always a simple matter. We may need to recognise not only that some of our perceptions differed from reality, but also that we must reconsider what we expected from the relationship, the possibilities we had attributed to it and the place we believed it would occupy in our lives.
When Idealisation Is Not an Illusion
It would, however, be unfair to regard idealisation exclusively as a distortion of reality. The positive image we create of another person may also be an expression of our love. When we love someone, we often notice aspects of their character that others may overlook. We recognise their potential, appreciate their small gestures and view certain weaknesses with greater understanding. A person who feels that they are seen with trust and appreciation may find within the relationship the space to express more of the positive aspects of themselves. Love is not limited to recording someone’s characteristics, as though we were attempting to create an objective portrait of them. It also encompasses the particular way in which that person comes to hold value for us.
Of particular interest here are the studies conducted by psychologists Sandra Murray, John Holmes and Dale Griffin on positive illusions in romantic relationships. The researchers found that partners’ tendency to perceive one another in a more positive and idealised way may be associated with greater relationship satisfaction. Such positive perceptions do not necessarily constitute an obstacle to intimacy. They may contribute to maintaining trust, appreciation and emotional closeness. This does not mean, of course, that every form of idealisation is beneficial or that love requires us to overlook behaviours that cause us pain. There is a difference between seeing someone with tenderness and refusing to acknowledge aspects of their character that have a significant bearing on our relationship.
Perhaps this difference lies in the flexibility of the image we have created. When our positive perception of another person can coexist with an awareness of their weaknesses, love need not be threatened by every disappointment. When, however, our image of them is so closely tied to our own expectations that we cannot accept anything that challenges it, idealisation may limit our ability to truly know them. Loving someone while recognising that they have difficulties is not the same as loving them in the belief that, sooner or later, those difficulties will disappear. In the first case, love meets the person in the present. In the second, it may remain directed towards a future version of that person, one that exists primarily in our imagination.
Meeting the Real Person
At some point, after several months together, Dora and Demosthenes spoke openly about what they wanted. She was looking for a relationship with greater emotional closeness, more time together and a gradual movement towards a shared life. Demosthenes, for his part, valued their relationship but did not desire the same kind of commitment. He needed more independence and was uncertain whether he wanted to change the way he had organised his life. Their conversation did not reveal a man who had pretended to be someone he was not. It revealed two people who, despite the attraction and tenderness between them, had different expectations. Dora began to understand that some of the qualities she had attributed to Demosthenes were not promises he had made. They were possibilities she herself had perceived, desires she had associated with his presence and images of a future they had never planned together.
Recognising this difference did not invalidate what they had experienced. Their beautiful encounters, their attraction, their tenderness and their moments of intimacy had been real. Demosthenes did not cease to be a person with qualities Dora admired simply because he did not want everything she wanted. What was changing was the image she had created of the place he would occupy in her life. Perhaps, for the first time, she could see him without needing to interpret his every action as a step towards the future she had imagined. And with this recognition came a different question: could she love Demosthenes as he truly was and, at the same time, acknowledge that their relationship might not be able to meet her own needs?
We often believe that accepting another person means remaining close to them, regardless of our differences. Yet recognising the person as they truly are does not necessarily mean continuing a relationship. We can understand their choices, appreciate their qualities and acknowledge the value of what we have shared without believing that we must adapt all our own desires to theirs. Love and compatibility are not always the same thing. Two people may feel deeply attracted to one another and nevertheless seek different kinds of relationships. This realisation can be painful, but it allows each person to recognise the other as a separate individual, with their own freedom and desires.
Perhaps, ultimately, there is no definitive answer to the question of whether we fall in love with the person we met or the one we imagined. At the beginning of a romance, these two images often coexist. The other person’s actual presence moves us, and our imagination adds expectations, desires and possibilities to that experience. Over time, however, getting to know someone offers us something that fantasy alone cannot provide: the opportunity to discover a person who exists independently of our own desires. Someone who may surprise us, disappoint us, move us in ways we had not anticipated or turn out to be different from the person we initially imagined.
And perhaps one of the most beautiful possibilities of love lies precisely in this encounter. In the moment when the person before us no longer needs to resemble the one we had dreamed of in order to continue to hold value for us.
