From My Notebook – Anna Karenina

CATEGORY: Stories That Left Their Mark



The Woman Who Wanted to Be Loved


There are literary characters who continue to occupy our thoughts long after we have closed the book. We wonder what they could have done differently, whether there was a moment when they might have changed the course of their lives, whether the people around them could have helped them. And then there are others who make us question the very nature of humanity. For me, Anna Karenina belongs to the latter category.

Reading Tolstoy’s novel, I found myself drawn not only to Anna’s great love for Vronsky or to the society that condemned her for her choice. What interested me most was Anna herself. The way she understood love, her need to maintain a particular place in the lives of those around her, her contradictions, her difficulty in accepting that her choices had consequences not only for herself but also for those who loved her. And the more I observed her behaviour, the more I wondered: did Anna love the people in her life for who they were, or for who she could be through their love?


A Woman Who Discovered Another Life


When we first meet Anna, we encounter a charming, intelligent woman with remarkable social grace. She is married to an important government official, has a son whom she loves and occupies an enviable position in the society of her time. Her marriage to Karenin does not appear to offer her the emotional fulfilment she might desire. Yet, before meeting Vronsky, we do not see her actively seeking a different life. It is his presence that reveals a side of herself she may never have known before.

Vronsky looks at her differently. He desires her, admires her, seeks her company. And through his gaze, Anna discovers a woman capable of inspiring passion, of being deeply moved, of feeling that life still has something exciting to offer her. It is easy to understand the allure of such an experience. After all, who among us has never felt that, through an encounter with another person, we have discovered something new about ourselves?

What is particularly interesting in Anna’s case is that this new image of herself gradually becomes so important that maintaining it seems to depend entirely on the person who revealed it to her. Vronsky is no longer simply the man she loves. He is also the person through whom she feels desirable, special, alive. And perhaps this is why, when she later begins to doubt his love, the threat she experiences is far greater than the possibility of a separation.


Her Love for Sergei


Anna’s relationship with her son is perhaps the one that troubled me most. Sergei is one of the most beloved people in her life. The thought of him moves her, his absence causes her pain, and her longing to see him again is profound. We could not easily question her love for him. We might, however, question the way in which she loves him.

Sergei is perhaps the only person in her life who continues to love her without judging her. And I wonder whether, for Anna, her son’s love also serves as reassurance that, despite her choices and the rejection she experiences, she remains a loved and significant woman.

Her visit on his birthday is one of the most moving scenes in the novel. Anna secretly returns to the house where she once lived to see her child. Little Sergei wakes, recognises his mother and embraces her. For a few moments, the two are together again. It is difficult for the reader to remain unmoved by their reunion. And yet, when I read this particular scene, I could not help wondering what would happen within the child’s heart when his mother left him once more.

Sergei had already been forced to come to terms with her absence. The adults around him had created a reality in which his mother no longer had a place, even going so far as to tell him that she had died. And suddenly, she appears, embraces him, reassures him of her love and, shortly afterwards, leaves again, unable to promise him when she will see him next. What might this encounter have meant to him? How much joy, but also how much confusion? How much hope, but also how much pain?

Anna had every reason to want to see her son. Her exclusion from his life was not entirely her own choice. What concerns me, however, is whether, before making this visit, she had considered what their reunion and the inevitable separation that followed might do to her child. Whether she had tried to see the situation not only through her own need to embrace him, but also through Sergei’s need to feel secure.

Because there are moments when loving another person asks something very difficult of us: to consider whether what will bring us relief is truly what the other person needs.


The Child of Her Great Love


Anna’s relationship with the daughter she has with Vronsky is also particularly interesting. One might expect that this child, born of a love for which Anna risked almost everything, would occupy an equally important place in her life. And yet, Tolstoy presents us with a mother whose emotional investment in little Annie is very different from that in Sergei.

This difference is not easy to explain. Her daughter was born during an exceptionally difficult period, when Anna came close to losing her life. The child became associated with a new reality that included separation from her son, social isolation and, later, insecurity within her relationship with Vronsky. Perhaps the little girl’s presence reminded Anna, without her fully realising it, not only of what she had gained but also of what she had lost.

There is, however, another aspect worth considering. Sergei is a child who can express his love for her, seek her out and show her how important she is in his life. Little Annie, by contrast, is at an age when she primarily needs to receive care. She cannot yet offer Anna the same reassurance or reflect back to her, through words and gestures, the image of a beloved mother.

I therefore wonder whether Anna found it more difficult to devote herself to a relationship in which she was primarily called upon to give. Whether the love she could receive from Sergei had acquired a significance for her that her little daughter was not yet able to offer.

We do not know whether this was the reality of her inner world. What we do know, however, is that a child needs to be loved regardless of what they represent in their parent’s life. And perhaps little Annie is one of the most overlooked figures in the tragedy of Anna Karenina.


Two Men and a Woman Who Wants Them to Reconcile


One of the scenes that made a particularly strong impression on me is the one in which Anna, seriously ill following the birth of her daughter, asks her husband to forgive Vronsky. Believing herself to be close to death, she wishes to restore something of what has fallen apart in her life. Karenin responds with a generosity of spirit that perhaps neither she nor Vronsky had expected from him.

We could interpret this moment as a sincere desire for reconciliation. Yet I cannot help being troubled by the fact that Anna does not simply ask her husband to forgive her for what has happened between them. She also wishes to determine the relationship between the two men. She wants Karenin to forgive the man with whom she betrayed him. She wants Vronsky to accept that forgiveness. In a sense, she wants harmony to be restored between two people whose lives have been changed by her choices.


And here I wonder: who would find the greatest relief in this reconciliation?


Karenin had every right to feel hurt, angry and betrayed. Vronsky had every right to experience his own discomfort, his own guilt, his own difficulties in facing the husband of the woman he loved. Anna, however, seems to need the two men to stop being in conflict at that particular moment. Perhaps because their conflict continually reminded her of the consequences of her own choices. Perhaps because she needed to feel that she could retain the love of one and the forgiveness of the other.

The desire to be forgiven by someone we have hurt is deeply human. There is, however, an important difference between asking for forgiveness and expecting another person to overcome their pain so that we can feel better. The person who has been hurt has a journey of their own to undertake. And that journey is under no obligation to end where we would like it to.


Vronsky and the Right to Have a Life of His Own


At the beginning of their relationship, Vronsky is a man who wants to be close to Anna, who pursues her love and is willing to make significant changes in his life for her sake. As time passes, however, Anna finds it increasingly difficult to accept that he may continue to have interests, responsibilities and desires that do not revolve entirely around their relationship.

A social engagement, a meeting, a visit to his mother, an absence longer than she had expected can all become sources of doubt and conflict. Anna constantly seeks proof that she remains the most important person in his life. And whenever he wishes to devote himself to something that does not involve her, she risks interpreting it as a sign that his love has begun to diminish.

Of course, we cannot ignore the fact that the two did not enjoy the same freedom. Vronsky was able to retain a significant part of his social life, while Anna had lost much of her own. He could temporarily step away from their relationship and return to a world that still accepted him. She had increasingly fewer places where she could feel that she belonged. This inequality made her dependence on his presence even greater.

Yet Vronsky could not become her entire world without losing a significant part of his own. He could not be constantly responsible for her happiness, anticipate every fear or prove at every moment that he still loved her. And perhaps this is where one of Anna’s most painful contradictions lies: while she had claimed the right to be free, she found it increasingly difficult to recognise that same freedom in the man for whom she had left her former life behind.


When Love Becomes a Demand


There is something deeply human about Anna’s desire to be loved. We all need to feel that we matter to the people we love. We can all be hurt when we realise that our place in someone’s life has changed. What distinguishes the way we relate to others, however, is what we do when this desire is not fulfilled.

Anna struggles to accept that the people around her may feel differently from the way she would like them to. Her husband may not wish to forgive her. Her son may have needs that do not coincide with her own desire to see him. Vronsky may love her and, at the same time, need space for himself. Society may have formed an opinion of her that she cannot change, however unjust it may be.

Gradually, Anna seems to be fighting not only for the love of these people but also to preserve the particular way in which she wishes to be loved. And the more she tries to secure her place in their lives, the greater the risk of driving them away.

Vronsky, who initially wanted to be constantly by her side, begins to feel that his every action may be called into question. Karenin, who for a moment manages to rise above his personal suffering and forgive her, once again finds himself facing a situation he cannot manage. Sergei grows up deprived of his mother, while little Annie finds herself in a family that is increasingly falling apart.

And Anna herself, who embarked on this journey in search of a life more closely aligned with her desires, ends up living in constant fear of losing the person upon whom her happiness has come to depend.


Her Final Choice


In the final pages of the novel, Tolstoy allows us to follow Anna’s thoughts very closely. The woman who once captivated those around her now finds herself in a state of profound loneliness. Her thoughts become increasingly dark, her trust in others diminishes, and even the most ordinary scenes of everyday life take on an unpleasant quality for her. She seems unable to imagine a life different from the one she is living, or any way of escaping her pain.

And yet, even shortly before her death, Vronsky remains at the centre of her thoughts. Alongside her desire to free herself from her suffering, we can discern a wish to make him suffer, to make him regret his actions, to make him realise what he has lost. In her mind, death appears not only as the end of her own misery but also as an act that will change his life forever.

I would not wish to reduce her tragedy to a desire for revenge. Anna is now a deeply desperate and isolated woman who has lost the ability to recognise other possibilities for her life. Nevertheless, we cannot overlook the fact that, even in her despair, she remains concerned with the place she will occupy in Vronsky’s mind. As though she cannot relinquish the need to determine what he will feel about her, even after she is gone.

And Tolstoy does not bring his story to an end with her death. He allows us to glimpse something of the life that continues after her. Vronsky, a devastated man who has lost interest in his own life and leaves for war. Their daughter, whom Karenin takes responsibility for raising. The people who must continue to live with the consequences of a story that did not end with the woman at its centre.


What Can We Take Away from Anna’s Story?


Epilogue


When I closed the book, I felt that the story of Anna Karenina, despite the distance that separates us from her era, still speaks deeply to the human experience today. Societies change, attitudes evolve, and the rules that shape human relationships are transformed, yet certain questions remain unchanged. How far can we go in pursuing our own happiness? How much room do we leave for others to exist within our desires? And what happens when, in our attempt to escape a life that no longer fulfils us, we create another from which we can no longer escape?

Anna had the courage to question the life she had been given. Yet she was unable to create a life that could retain its value even without Vronsky’s love. In seeking her freedom, she gradually surrendered to another person the power to determine her happiness. And when she felt him drifting away, she could no longer see a different life ahead of her. She saw the end of her life.

Perhaps this is the most tragic aspect of her story. Not that she loved a man more than the society of her time would allow, but that she reached a point where she could no longer imagine herself beyond his love.

Tolstoy leaves us not only with the image of a woman who was lost, but also with the lives of those who remained behind. For although the curtain may fall for Anna, the story continues for the people who loved her.

And perhaps our greatest responsibility in love is this: never to forget that the people we love are not the characters in our own story. They are the protagonists of their own.

The End…

PsyCatherine.com

Our Blog Timeline

Scroll to Top